Tuesday, November 11, 2008
Xavier is a Registered Nurse who specialized in complex wound care. He has practiced for over fourteen years in his community. He often provided nursing service in areas where law enforcement refused to enter without back-up. Xavier now works in surgery. Xavier has been an avid shooter for over 30 years. He strongly supports the 2nd Amendment, opposes gun control of any sort, and carries a weapon 24 hours a day. Xavier is known on various internet gun forums as XavierBreath. He is married with three children, and is moderated by an apathetic one eyed cat, a goofy Golden Retriever, and a stalwart German Shepherd Dog. One day, he hopes to be deserving of them all.
Domari Nolo
Xavier can still be emailed at
treatmewithbenignneglect@gmail.com
He might read your email.
He might delete it on sight.
He might publish it and comment on it.
The Four Rules
1. All firearms are always loaded
2. Never let the muzzle of a firearm point at anything you are not willing to destroy
3. Keep your finger off the trigger until you are ready to shoot
4. Be sure of your target and what lies beyond it
The Five Rules of Concealed Carry
1. Your concealed handgun is for protection of life only.
2. Know exactly when you can use your gun.
3. If you can run away -- RUN!
4. Display your gun, be prepared to go to jail.
5. Don't let your emotions get the best of you.
Gunnie Type Blogs
& Links
-
U.S. Concealed Carry Assoc.
Open Carry.org
The Cornered Cat
Learn About Guns
No Nonsense Self Defense
Armchair Gun Show
Jeff Cooper's Commentaries
Massad Ayoob
Pistol Training.com
Listening to Katrina
Civilian Gun Self-Defense
Front Sight, Press
Revolver Liberation Alliance
Women of Caliber
Sharp as a Marble
View From The Porch
Home on the Range
CarteachO
The Drawn Cutlass
3 Boxes of BS
Oleg Volk
The Thinking Gunfighter
The Lawdog Files
Gun Nuts Media
Expert Witness
Mauser Girl
Gunning and Strumming
The Firearm Blog
N.U.G.U.N.
Squeaky Wheel
The Munchkin Wrangler
Fatal Abstraction
Better And Better
Mauser Medic
The Armed School Teacher
Cowtown Cop
Legally Armed In Detroit
Guns, Crime and Videotape
AnarchAngel
Bloggo
From the Barrel of a Gun
The Shootist
A Keyboard and a .45
Politics, Guns & Beer
Kingside Rook
TFS Magnum
Pretty Pistolera
Gun Pundit
Bayou Renaissance Man
Firearm Fun
Boomers & BS
Armed and Safe
Thoran's Thoughts
Gunner's Journal
Monster Hunter Nation
Curses! Foiled Again!
Alphecca
Women of Caliber
Guns Holsters & Gear
Mr.Completely
Roberta X
Days of our Trailers
Wasted Electrons
Cogito Ergo Geek
The Breda Fallacy
7 Plus 8
Poet n The Pawnbroker
The Real Gun Guys
John Lott's Website
Hell in a Handbasket
Michael Bane
10 Ring
Live from the (upper) Texas Gulf Coast
Geek With A .45
Nursing Type Blogs
+ A Few Docs
Weird Nursing TalesNurse William
Nurse Ratched's Place
Scalpel or Sword?
Pink Warm Dry
Float Floor RN
White Coat Rants
Dust In The Wind
Musings of a Highly Trained Monkey
GuitarGirl RN
Donorcycle
Grunt Doc
Nursing School Insanity
White Coat Underground
Surgeon's Blog
Crass-Pollination
Cut To Cure
Backboards and Band-Aids
Code Blog
Street Watch
Pixel RN
Brain Scramble
Mostly True Stories
Nursing Zen
Angry Nurse
Hot Medical News
Podunk Memorial
March of the Platypi
Medicated Musings
10 Out Of 10
Ambulance Driver
Too Old To Work, Too Young to Retire
Rogue Medic
I Just Call It As I See It
Bicycling Blogs and Sites
Transportational BicyclingBike Hacks
Paul Dorn's Bike Commuting Tips
Classic Rendezvous
Cyclelicious
Sheldon Brown
Jim Langley
Bike Commuters
Commute by Bike
Bike Snob
The Well Run Dry
Lunatic Biker
Old Bike Blog
Sixty-one Sixty
Austin Bike Blog
Ghost Bike
Bike Whenever
Velocipede
The Slow Bicycle Movement
Amsterdamize
Lock Your Bike
Old Rusty Bike
2whls3spds
Chic Cyclist
Velocipete
63xc
Spokes of a Wheel
Bicycling New Orleans
What I Saw Riding my Bike around Today
Velo-Orange
3 Speed Blog
Bikes for the Rest of Us
Alien Bikes
The Bike Geek
Old Ten Speed Gallery
Fixed Gear Gallery
Cyclofiend
Bike Rubbish
Bicycle Design
Bike of Doom
Bike Jax
Industry Outsider
Fat Cyclist
Rogue Mechanic
The Accidental Athlete
Clever Cycles
Copenhagen Cycle Chic
Bike Drool
Grease Monkey
How To Fix Bikes
Bike Fix
Montreal Freak Bike Militia
Freakbike Nation
Bicycle Tutor
Vintage Life Cycles
Where Was My Bike Made?
Yehuda Moon
National Weather Service
Photography Blogs and Sites
Ken RockwellThom Hogan
Peter Van Nugteren
Lighten Up & Shoot
Vivian Maier
Steve McCurry
Eric Meola
Richard Avedon
Joyce Tenneson
Joe McNally
Edward P. Richards
Roger Clark
Zack Arias
Neil Van Niekerk
Laurin Rinder
Marty Kittrell
Bjorn Rorslett
Michael Fatali
Oleg Volk
Scott Kelby
Dave Black
kelco
Jack Heinemann
Russ Morris
Richard de Stoutz Nikon Collection
Tinker and Wander
Through the Viewfinder
Digital Howie Photoworks
Shutter Fug
Reactuate
50% Chance of Rain
And Then Came the Shot
Strobist
2 Point 8
Stuck in Customs
Stupid Photographer
Digital SLR and Lens Review
Weegee's World
Tokyo Camera Style
Holga Mods.com
1x.com
Studio Lighting.net
Enticing the Light
TimeCatcher
The Online Photographer
Photodoto
Collectible Cameras
The Living Image
Old Cameras
Michael C Liu's
Photoaxe.com
Field Cameras of the United States
Holga
Michael C Liu's
Nikon & Nikkors Resources
Camerapedia
The Photographer's Right (pdf)
Digital Photography School
Other Blogs I Like
The ConsumeristPost Secret
Bent Objects
“Unnecessary” Quotation Marks
Astronomy Pic of the Day
Steampunk
Mental Floss
Gawker
Photo Basement
Dark Roasted Blend
Oobject
Knutz
Life Hacker
Geekologie
Today's Big Thing
Deal Hack
2 Spyware.com
1-800 Numbers
Ilsa's Favorites
Lagniappe's LairAbby K9
ARDA
Schwartze-Hunden
GSD Club of America
Purina
Specific Archives
Idiots with Guns
Range Reports
Self Defense
NOLA Confiscation Video
Patricia Konie Video
Ashton O'Dwyer Video
The Untold Story of Gun Confiscation After Katrina
22 Comments:
So far 100% of the KBs I've seen have involved reloads.
Coincidence?
Double charge.
Actually, from the thread it look like _under_ charge was the fault(still reload problem), the powder used can't even be double charged(wouldn't fit in the case).
Enough charge to make enough pressure that it has to come out, not enough to move the bullet out of the way, apparently.
Anon:
If you read the thread, he used 27gr of H110. A double charge won't fit in that case.
27 grains??? Holy freaking overload Batman! Thats nearly a double charge, of powder thats high pressure to start with.
I would like to see the piece that came off.
From the photos, it looks like you could place the broken cylinder on a flat surface and all four broken surfaces would touch the table.
it would be interesting to see whether the bit that came off is all bulged to hell, or if it has that same straight break. If it has the straight break, it might suggest a flaw in the metal the cylinder was made from
- they happen sometimes
but dodgy reloads seem much more common.
Keith
I don't know anything about reloading, so my comments are limited.
The consensus on the thread seems be that he made a reloading error of some sort.
If I were S&W I'd want that gun back at the factory so it could be examined. Just to be sure that it wasn't a manufacturing defect. It would be worth their while to give him a brand new gun, just for the positive PR value.
carteach0, if you go to Hodgdon data site you will find that 27.5g is their recommended starting load. Best guess is either a faulty cylinder that failed or much more likely, a serous under load that caused a massive pressure spike. It happens, rare, but it happens.
Grendel
Carteach, per the thread, the IMR website calculated the load as being a little on the light side. They recommend starting at 27.5 grains of H110.
Now let me teach all of you something exceedingly important about the metallurgy of Aluminum Alloys. (This was an Aluminum Scandium Alloy gun.)
There is a thing in metallurgy called the fatigue limit. For steel it is generally 1/10 of yield strength (not UTS or Ultimate Tensile Strength). That means that you can stress the part to 1/10 of Yield forever and it will not ever form cracks. This is more or less true with (almost) all metals. The percentage of yield varies by alloy and alloy group, but they all have a value at which you can stress the part forever and never fail the part.
This is not true of Aluminum. Aluminum is unique in the metallurgical world in that it has no fatigue limit. There is no level of stress that when applied repeatedly will never fail the part. (Technically that is not true, some recent studies have found a fatigue limit that is around 1/1000th of yield, but that is so low as to be virtually irrelevant.) That is why aircraft are constantly inspected for cracking. Now the magnitude of the stress and the rapidity of the onset of cracking are related to each other more or less linearly, The higher the stresses, the quicker it will fail. But they will ALL fail eventually.
Additionally, Most aluminum alloys are "precipitation hardened" meaning that they are subjected to a special heat treating regime in which elements that are dissolved into the alloy begin to precipitate out of solution into the grains and grain boundaries of the crystalline structure. these act as "locks" to prevent grains from moving past each other during stress. The problem is that many of these alloys continue to precipitate these elements throughout their lives, especially when they are subjected to elevated temperatures for long periods of time. Eventually the grain structure is so full of these precipitates that the internal stresses of the grain structure are overcome and the grain structure ruptures, causing microcracks throughout the alloy. this leads to both intergranular corrosion, and the cracks can also marge to form larger and larger cracks.
Knowing what I know about the metallurgy of aluminum alloys. I WILL NOT OWN AN ALUMINUM GUN.
How is it possible to have an under-charge detonation with such a high-volume powder?
I always assumed light-charge detonation happened in BIG cases with small charges of powder.
Carteach - No, it's not. If you read the thread, thr starting loads seem to be right around 27.5. If anything, it was apparently an under-loaded round. (as others have stated)
200 GR. NOS JHP Hodgdon H110 .429" 1.600" 27.5 1708 29,000 CUP 28.5 1806 37,800 CUP
H110 is believed to be subject to detonation when underloaded. Now while 27.0 is .5 under Hodgdon's start load, it is well within the range given in Hornady's 7th ed, which gives a range of 26.3 - 29.5 grains of that powder.
Double charge is impossible with that powder.
6th round fired from that revolver. (Brand New). Most likely the first round fired from that chamber. I actually have to think that it was a defect in the grain structure of the cylinder.
Eh, it looks as though he's still got three good chambers, not to mention that the gun is significantly lighter than it was before, which was probably part of the reason he bought it.
Who fires reloads out of an airweight ? I'd be scared to even use +P factory rounds. Is it possible that it was something like a squib (similar to what mikael suggested), maybe due to a burr in the forcing cone or something like that?
that is CLASSIC detonation...notice the the REAR of the cylindar is "clean" and the rest is "charred" around the bullet/crimp area??
Its REAL easy to double charge a reload if you're not paying attention. In fact, my setup consistently throws a double charge on the first reload. Not sure why, but that powder always goes back in the hopper. Rest are 100%.
I'm not a reloader or a metalurgist, but I am a former factory warranty guy (not for firearms). I'd want that gun back just to examine for manufacturing defects. And no, I wouldn't give him a new one. If the design is sound, and proven in the field, and you trusst your processes then it's sound to question the use or applicaation. Just my opinion.
Mike
329PD, eh?
I have two Ti-cylindered wheelguns (sold the 325PD) and they have one thing in common: While the rest of the gun gets cleaned like a regular firearm, the cylinder itself only gets a rubdown with a lubed cotton patch, and then only rarely. I live in mortal fear of disrupting the voodoo coating that prevents flame erosion and crack propagation in the titanium.
Rorschach,
Iron and iron based alloys ("Steels") are the only commonly used metals WITH a fatigue limit.
In ALL other commonly used metals, you can plot stress against frequency and they will give a straight line graph for fatigue failure.
That is why aircraft parts are given a "Life" before they must be changed (inspection for cracks is still necessary though).
Precipitation hardening may not be taken to completion during the heating used to speed precipitation, but further precipitation will take place at normal temperature (as it would even without the heating, the heating just speeds the process) but the degree of phase change is limited by the availability of alloying elements to form the new phase. Once they are all in the new phase, the process CAN NOT continue.
Are you confusing precipetation hardening with the different process of intergranular corrosion that was a problem with old zinc die castings which contained lead as an impurity?
Fatigue limit for Iron based alloys is about 1/2 of yield stress.
Generally, a gun will not be fired often enough for fatigue to be a problem. wear or corrosion will be a problem much sooner. Something like an IC engine will give you the several million reversals within a few hours of running, and anything loaded above its fatigue limit will fail in that time. everything there is well lubricated and cooled so wear is not so rapid.
With guns (even machineguns) the max allowable stress on any part is the yeild stress, and a factor of safety of root 2 to root 3 is normally applied to allow for material and machining defects.
Casting and rolling flaws do occasionally occur, even in carefully prepared metals, and sometimes there is segregation of alloying or impurity elements, which leave a plane of weakness. Under many jurisdictions, these would be identified by firing with a proof charge.
I have my suspicions about this failure. It would certainly be interesting to know.
On page 337 of the 48th edition of the Lyman Reloading Manual we see that for a 180 gr jacketed bullet the MAX load of H110 is 14.5 grains. This guy was loading a heavier bullet (which takes less powder) at 27 grains, or almost exactly double the max published load...
On page 337 of the 48th edition of the Lyman Reloading Manual we see that for a 180 gr jacketed bullet the MAX load of H110 is 14.5 grains.
You must be reading that incorrectly. I looked at my collection of manuals for .44 magnum loads using a 200 grain JHP and find the following:
Hornady #4: 26.6 - 29.1 for the 200 grain XTP.
Hodgdon #26: 26-27 grains.
Speer #11: 25.5-27.5 grains.
So they were definitely hot, but nowhere near the degree implied by your post.
I'm thinkin' Les was lookin' at the .357 data...... I was thinkin' "That's a damned HOT load!", too, untill I figured out that it was a .44 ......
Post a Comment
<< Home